Rotator Cuff or Frozen Shoulder? Shoulder Physio Bexley North & Marrickville Spot the Difference
Sore shoulder that will not lift, or will not move at all? Here is how to tell a rotator cuff problem from a frozen shoulder, and how our award winning physios help.
- Same day appointments
- No referral needed
- Clear diagnosis at your first visit
- ⭐5.0 Google Rating240+ reviews
- 🏆2026 Award WinnerBayside Business Awards
- ⏱️60 Minute First VisitFind the real cause
- 💳HICAPSClaim on the spot
Rotator Cuff vs Frozen Shoulder explained
Rotator Cuff or Frozen Shoulder: What Is the Difference?
Your rotator cuff is a group of four muscles and tendons that steady and lift your arm. When they get overloaded or torn, lifting hurts and feels weak. A frozen shoulder is different: the joint capsule itself tightens and thickens, so the shoulder slowly loses movement in every direction. The good news: both get better with the right physiotherapy.
Does This Sound Like Your Shoulder?
- Pain down the outside of your upper arm
- Can't reach behind your back or do up a bra
- Waking at night when you roll onto that side
- Lifting your arm out to the side pinches or catches
- Your shoulder is getting stiffer week by week
- Struggling to dress, wash your hair or lift at the gym
Who we see with shoulder pain
- 🏋️Gym goers and lifters
- 🔨Tradies working overhead
- 🏊Swimmers and throwers
- 🩺People with diabetes or thyroid conditions
- 🧺Busy parents and carers
- 👵Over 40s and 50s
Two Clinics, Same Day Appointments
Book a physio at Bexley North or Marrickville, whichever is closer to home, work or the gym. Same award winning team at both.
20 Shaw Street, Bexley North. Monday to Friday 7am to 7pm, Saturday 8am to 1pm.
Book Bexley North →Inside World Gym, 4 Carrington Road, Marrickville. Monday to Friday 8am to 7pm.
Book Marrickville →Spot the difference
Rotator Cuff vs Frozen Shoulder Side by Side
They can feel alike at first, but they behave very differently. Here is how a rotator cuff problem and a frozen shoulder usually compare.
Where it hurts
Outside of the upper arm, worse lifting out to the side or overhead
Deep in the shoulder, all over, sometimes spreading down the upper arm
What it feels like
A painful catch or pinch through the middle of a lift, often with weakness
A deep ache plus stiffness, like the shoulder is stuck or locked
Pain pattern
Comes and goes with load, worse after gym, overhead work or lying on it
Builds slowly over weeks, very painful early, then stiffness takes over
Can you lift your arm
Usually yes with help, even if lifting it yourself hurts or feels weak
Not far, even when someone else lifts it, especially out to the side or behind you
Common causes
Overload from gym, overhead work or sport, wear with age, or a fall
Often no clear cause, more common from 40 to 60 and with diabetes
Typical recovery
Often much better in 6 to 12 weeks, with strength building for up to 6 months
Moves through painful, stiff and thawing stages, often over 1 to 3 years
Best first step
A physio assessment and a progressive rotator cuff strength program
A physio assessment, pain relief strategies and gentle, regular movement within comfort
AIt is more likely your rotator cuff if lifting hurts and feels weak, but the arm still moves well when someone helps.
BIt is more likely a frozen shoulder if it is stiff in every direction, even when someone else moves your arm for you.
A physio assessment sorts it out, with same day appointments at Bexley North and Marrickville and a clear plan from your very first visit.
Real Shoulder Recoveries
★★★★★
I’ve been seeing Ari for 8weeks with a rotator cuff injury, so far the pain is so much better & slowly getting me back to been pain free whilst helping me with exercises & movement so I can still continue my normal routine
LouieTreated by Ari · Google review
★★★★★
Had a long term shoulder injury which was restricting movement and causing pain. Sam provided a structured plan and guidance to keep training safely. The pain is completely gone and previous strength is returning.
Ursula M.Treated by Sam · Google review
★★★★★
Sam is a great Physio. We’ve had great success treating my shoulders for chronic pain. He’s constantly troubleshooting trying to find the best treatments that are right for me, and he’s enthusiastic about the whole process.
Mathew E.Treated by Sam · Google review
More from our 240+ Google reviews
Rotator Cuff, Frozen Shoulder or Something Else?
Shoulder pain is not one thing. Your physiotherapist works out which of these is driving yours, because each one needs a different plan.
01Rotator Cuff Tendinopathy
Feels like: ache down the outside of your arm, worse lifting out to the side or lying on it.
The cuff tendons get overloaded, often after more gym, overhead work or sport. The shoulder still moves, and progressive strength work is the most proven fix.
Read about rotator cuff physio →02Rotator Cuff Tear
Feels like: weakness lifting your arm, sometimes after a fall or a heavy pull.
Part or all of a tendon is torn. Many do well with strength work, and we arrange a scan and surgical opinion quickly when needed.
03Frozen Shoulder
Feels like: deep ache, then stiffness, unable to reach behind your back or out to the side.
The joint capsule tightens and thickens, most often between 40 and 60. It moves through painful, stiff and thawing stages, and physio helps at each one.
Read about shoulder pain physio →04When Both Overlap
Feels like: started as a sore rotator cuff, now stiff in every direction.
A painful shoulder that is kept still can stiffen, and early frozen shoulder can look a lot like cuff pain. Testing movement and strength tells us what to treat first.
05Shoulder Arthritis
Feels like: stiff, grinding and achy, most often over 60.
Worn joint surfaces can stiffen a shoulder much like a frozen shoulder. An X ray tells them apart, and strength and movement work help both.
06Pain From Your Neck
Feels like: ache over the shoulder blade or down the arm, sometimes with tingling.
An irritated joint or nerve in the neck can refer pain into the shoulder. We check your neck so the right area gets treated.
Read about neck pain physio →Not sure which one you have? Call (02) 8021 0969
Your options
Why See a Physio First for Shoulder Pain?
Waiting it out, painkillers and massage can all take the edge off. Physiotherapy adds a clear diagnosis and the right plan for your rotator cuff or frozen shoulder.
Questions first? Call (02) 8021 0969
How Our Shoulder Physios Get You Moving
Whether it is your rotator cuff or a frozen shoulder, every plan is built around your work, sleep and training, from desk jobs to overhead trades and the gym.
- 1
Find the Cause
A full 60 minute assessment of strength and movement to tell a rotator cuff problem from a frozen shoulder.
- 2
Settle the Pain
Hands on treatment, better sleep positions and the right amount of movement for the stage you are in.
- 3
Build or Restore
Progressive strength for the rotator cuff, or gentle, regular movement to win back range in a frozen shoulder.
- 4
Back to Life
Reaching, lifting, sleeping and training again, with a plan to keep it that way.
Treatments we may use
- Dry needling
- Shockwave therapy
- Hands on therapy
- Individualised rehabilitation programming
Related conditions we treat
How Long Does Each Take to Get Better?
Rotator cuff pain and frozen shoulder recover on very different timelines. This is what it usually looks like with a physiotherapist guiding you.
- First 2 to 6 weeks
Settle the Pain
Most rotator cuff pain eases as we adjust your load. In early frozen shoulder, we focus on easing pain and keeping gentle movement.
- Weeks 6 to 12
Build Strength or Range
Rotator cuff strength builds and most people lift and sleep much better. A frozen shoulder may be at its stiffest around now.
- Months 3 to 12 and beyond
Strong and Moving
Cuff strength keeps building for up to 6 months. A frozen shoulder thaws gradually, often over 1 to 3 years in total.
Tears, surgery and stubborn frozen shoulders can take longer, and some people benefit from a GP or specialist opinion about injections. Your physio will give you your own timeline, or call (02) 8021 0969 to ask.
Your first appointment
What to Expect at Your First Shoulder Physio Appointment
60minutes, one on one
with your physio
Unlike many clinics, your first visit is a full 60 minutes. That time lets your physiotherapist test strength and movement properly, tell a rotator cuff problem from a frozen shoulder and build a clear plan with you.
What to wear and bring
- A singlet or loose top so we can see and test your shoulder
- Any scans, reports or referral letters you have
- Your health fund card, HICAPS lets you claim on the spot
Same day appointments available
- 0 to 10 min
Your Story
We listen to how your shoulder pain started, how it has changed, and what you want to get back to.
- 10 to 30 min
Movement and Strength Tests
We check how far your arm moves on its own and with help, test rotator cuff strength, and screen your neck.
- 30 to 40 min
Clear Explanation
You find out if it is your rotator cuff, a frozen shoulder or both, in plain English, and what recovery looks like.
- 40 to 55 min
Hands On Treatment
Hands on therapy and the right exercises for your stage, to ease your pain that same day.
- 55 to 60 min
Your Plan
A structured plan and two or three simple exercises, so you know exactly what to do next.
What You Can Do at Home for a Sore Shoulder
Three safe things that help most people with rotator cuff pain or a frozen shoulder while you wait for your appointment.
- 🛏️01
Hug a Pillow at Night
Sleep on your good side hugging a pillow, or on your back with a pillow under your sore arm.
- 🔄02
Keep It Gently Moving
Easy pendulum swings and reaching within comfort beat keeping your arm still in a sling.
- 🏋️03
Ease Off, Don't Stop
Drop the weight and skip painful overhead lifts for now, but keep training what feels fine.
Shoulder getting stiffer or weaker? Call (02) 8021 0969
?Quick answers
Rotator Cuff or Frozen Shoulder Quick Answers
Fast answers to the questions people search most about a sore, stiff shoulder.
How can I tell frozen shoulder from a rotator cuff problem?
Check the stiffness
With frozen shoulder the arm will not move far even when someone else lifts it. With a rotator cuff problem lifting hurts and feels weak, but the arm usually still moves when helped.
Can you lift your arm with frozen shoulder?
Only partly
Usually only part of the way. Frozen shoulder limits movement in every direction, especially reaching out to the side and behind your back, even when someone helps lift the arm.
Can a rotator cuff injury cause frozen shoulder?
Sometimes
It can. A painful shoulder that stops moving can stiffen, and some people develop frozen shoulder after an injury or surgery. Gentle, guided movement helps lower that risk.
Does frozen shoulder go away on its own?
Usually, slowly
Most frozen shoulders improve over time, often across 1 to 3 years. Physio eases the pain and helps you keep and regain movement through each stage, so daily life is easier along the way.
Is rotator cuff pain or frozen shoulder worse at night?
Both can be
Both often ache at night. Rotator cuff pain usually flares when you lie on that side, while early frozen shoulder can ache constantly. Hugging a pillow or resting the arm on one helps.
Do I need a scan to tell them apart?
Usually not
Most of the time a hands on assessment of strength and movement tells them apart. An ultrasound can check the rotator cuff, and an X ray can rule out arthritis if needed.
When to See a Physio, a Doctor, or Get a Scan
Most shoulder pain is not dangerous, but a few warning signs need urgent care. Here is how your physiotherapist decides what you need.
✓Book a Physio If
These are the most common reasons people see us.
- Lifting your arm out to the side or overhead hurts
- Your shoulder is slowly getting stiffer
- Pain wakes you at night or stops you lying on that side
- It stops you working, training or dressing easily
!See a GP or Hospital Now If
These red flags need urgent medical care.
- Shoulder or arm pain with chest pain, shortness of breath, sweating or jaw pain (call 000)
- Obvious deformity or the shoulder has popped out and stayed out
- Hot, red, swollen shoulder with fever
- Sudden numbness or weakness down the arm
- Unexplained weight loss, a new lump or a history of cancer
?Do You Need a Scan?
Most people do not need one straight away.
- An ultrasound or MRI can check for a tear if you cannot lift your arm after a fall or pull
- An X ray helps rule out arthritis or calcium build up when a shoulder is very stiff
- If you need one, we liaise with your GP or specialist for you
Unsure if it is urgent? Call (02) 8021 0969
🏆 2026 Award Winner
Meet Your Award Winning Shoulder Physios
Winners of Outstanding Health Improvement Services at the Bayside Local Business Awards 2026, treating rotator cuff injuries and frozen shoulder in Bexley North and Marrickville every day.
Julian De Rosa
Physiotherapist Head physio for Fraser Park FC with a Master of Physiotherapy. Has competed in ICN natural bodybuilding and is passionate about helping people with lower back pain and chronic pain.
Read bio →
Sam Nunan
Physiotherapist Head physio for the Wests Tigers reserve grade team in the NSW Cup, and formerly with the Canterbury Bulldogs junior pathways. Loves powerlifting, cricket and rugby league.
Read bio →
Ari Moushis
Physiotherapist An Ironman triathlete who is excellent with runners, cyclists and swimmers, with a background in powerlifting, tennis and golf.
Read bio →
Easy Ways to Access Shoulder Physio
Claim your shoulder physiotherapy on the spot with HICAPS and your health fund, or use a Medicare care plan, DVA, Workers Comp or CTP.
- 💳Private Health InsuranceAll major health funds. Claim on the spot if you have extras cover.
- 🩺Medicare Care PlanHave a GP care plan? Bring it along and we'll handle the rest.
- 🎖️DVAVeterans with a DVA referral are bulk billed.
- 👷Workers CompensationSIRA approved. We liaise with your doctor and insurer.
- 🚗Car Accident (CTP)SIRA approved CTP physiotherapy after a road accident.
- 🤝NDISSelf managed and plan managed participants welcome.
Not sure if you're covered? Call (02) 8021 0969 and we'll check for you.
Before You Book
Rotator Cuff or Frozen Shoulder Questions, Answered
Quick answers about telling a rotator cuff problem from a frozen shoulder, from our shoulder physios in Bexley North and Marrickville. Still unsure? Call us on (02) 8021 0969 and we'll help you out.
Physio Bexley North
20 Shaw Street, Bexley North NSW 2207
Monday to Friday 7am to 7pm
Saturday 8am to 1pm
Physio Marrickville
4 Carrington Road, inside World Gym, Marrickville NSW 2204
Monday to Friday 8am to 7pm
The big clue is stiffness. With frozen shoulder the arm will not move far even when someone else lifts it. With a rotator cuff problem lifting hurts and feels weak, but the arm usually still moves when helped.
It can happen. A painful shoulder that you stop moving can stiffen, and some people develop frozen shoulder after an injury or surgery. Keeping it gently moving with guidance helps lower the risk.
It is most common between 40 and 60, more often in women, and in people with diabetes or thyroid conditions. It often starts for no clear reason.
It usually moves through painful, stiff and thawing stages over 1 to 3 years, though many people improve sooner. Physio eases the pain and keeps you moving at each stage.
Not always. A hands on assessment usually tells them apart. An ultrasound can show the rotator cuff tendons, and an X ray helps rule out arthritis in a stiff shoulder. If you need one, we arrange it through your GP.
No. You can book straight in at Bexley North or Marrickville, with same day appointments most days. You only need a referral for a Medicare care plan, DVA, Workers Compensation or CTP.
Your first visit is a full 60 minutes, one on one. That gives us time to test your strength and movement, find the real cause and build a clear, structured plan.
Yes. We have HICAPS at both clinics, so you can claim on the spot. We also see Medicare care plan, DVA, Workers Compensation and CTP patients.
Ready to Feel Like Yourself Again?
Same day shoulder physio in Bexley North and Marrickville, no referral needed, and an award winning team to tell your rotator cuff from a frozen shoulder.
Find Your Shoulder Physio
Two award winning clinics. Bexley North for Kingsgrove, Earlwood, Bardwell Park, Bexley and Rockdale. Marrickville inside World Gym for Dulwich Hill, Sydenham, Petersham, Tempe and the Inner West.
Physio Bexley North
20 Shaw Street, Bexley North NSW 2207
Monday to Friday 7am to 7pm, Saturday 8am to 1pm
Physio near
- Kingsgrove
- Bardwell Park
- Earlwood
- Bexley
- Rockdale
- Turrella
Physio Marrickville
4 Carrington Road, inside World Gym
Monday to Friday 8am to 7pm, private on site parking
Physio near
- Dulwich Hill
- Sydenham
- Petersham
- Newtown
- Tempe
- Enmore
Rotator Cuff or Frozen Shoulder? Find Out Today
Book a 60 minute shoulder physiotherapy assessment in Bexley North, close to Kingsgrove, Earlwood and Bardwell Park, or Marrickville for Dulwich Hill, Sydenham and the Inner West. Same day appointments, no referral needed.
- 2026 Award Winner
- 5.0 from 240+ Google reviews
- Same day appointments
- No referral needed
- HICAPS claim on the spot
Got a Question? Contact Us
Not sure if it is your rotator cuff or a frozen shoulder, or if a physio is the right first step? Our admin team is happy to help.
Bexley North: Mon to Fri 7am to 7pm, Sat 8am to 1pmMarrickville: Mon to Fri 8am to 7pm
Send an Enquiry
🏆 Award Winning Clinic 2026
Your Journey to Better Health Starts With an Award Winning Team
Same day appointments available